(Dossier Colin Rowe) Notes for an Intellectual Biography of Colin Rowe (1938-78)

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.12795/astragalo.2024.i35.11

Keywords:

Colin Rowe, metahistorical approach, neoclassical classicism, utopian modernism, urban design

Abstract

This article draws on Colin Rowe's experience as a paratrooper during the war as a metaphor for his ability to cope with diverse and complex circumstances. It highlights different periods of his life, from his peripatetic trajectory (1938-78) to his time at various institutions and the culmination of his 40-year career. Rowe navigated professional changes thanks to three stabilizing codes: a neoclassical classicism influenced by Wittkower, a modernism with utopian ideals influenced by Le Corbusier, and a third imaginary space that allowed for new cultural interpretations. These codes were reflected in his urban projects in Texas, Cornell, and Cambridge. Throughout his career, Rowe adopted and adapted these codes, reflecting his initial rejection of the Georgian city, his commitment to modern utopia, and his eventual rediscovery of the neoclassical city. Rowe's work, including his meta-city Roma Interrotta, illustrates his ability to integrate the modern and the classical in an urban context, using a metahistorical approach that anticipates the transformation of cities into spaces of recombinant information and memory. The exhibition of Roma Interrotta at the Trajan Market in 1978 and its recreation at the MAXXI Museum in 2014 underscore his vision of the city as a museum and a space of memory. This perspective translates into an architecture that not only responds to contemporary needs but also dialogues with history, showcasing Rowe's ability to create urban spaces rich in meaning and potential, a timeless hybrid that connects the personal and the collective.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Author Biography

David Grahame Shane, GSAPP Columbia University

David Grahame Shane is Adjunct Professor in the Urban Design program at Columbia GSAPP.

Shane studied architecture at the Architectural Association, London, graduating in 1969 with his Dream City Thesis published in the AA125 Volume (1972). He continued with an M.Arch in Urban Design (1971) and then an Architectural and Urban History Ph.D. (1978) with Colin Rowe at Cornell University. Professor Rowe incorporated Shane’s Urban Patterns in London drawing into Collage City (1978). He wrote Recombinant Urbanism: Conceptual Modeling in Architecture, Urban Design and City Theory (2005) and co-edited with Brian McGrath the Architectural Design title Sensing the 21st Century City: Close-Up and Remote (2005). Urban Design Since 1945; a Global Perspective (2011). Since 1999 Shane has participated in the UD PhD program at the IUAV Venice with Professors Secchi and Vigano and is also currently a Visiting Professor at the Milan Polytechnic and ETS Architecture in Seville.

References

Arnheim, Rudolf. 1954. Art and Visual Perception: A Psychology of the Creative Eye. Univ of California Press, Berkeley.

Banham, Mary, and Bevis Hillier. 1951. A Tonic to the Nation: The Festival of Britain: 1951. London: Thames and Hudson.

Benelli, Francesco. 2010. “Rudolf Wittkower e Colin Rowe: Continuità e Frattura In: Marzo, M Ed.” L’architettura Come Testo e La Figura Di Colin Rowe, 72-95, 97–111.

Centanni, Monica. 2010. “Per Una Iconologia Dell’intervallo. Tradizione Dell’antico e Visione Retrospettiva in Aby Warburg e Colin Rowe.” In L’architettura Come Testo e La Figura Di Colin Rowe, 59–72. Marsilio Editori.

Braghieri, Gianni. 1991. Aldo Rossi: Works and Projects. Barcelona: Gustavo Gili.

Braghieri, Gianni 1976. The Analogue City Map.https://www.researchgate.net/publication/280530086_The_Analogous_City_The_Map]. Consultado el 12/9/2018.

Bunschoten, Raoul. 1985. “Collage City: A Masquerade of Fragment Utopias.” Daidalos, no. 16: 31–42.

Caragonne, Alexander. 1995. The Texas Rangers: Notes from an Architectural Underground. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.

Cassirer, Ernst. n.d. The Platonic Renaissance in England. London: Thomas Nelson and Sons.

Cerruti, M. 1978. Roma Interrotta. Rome: officina edizioni.

Crinson, Mark. 2012. Stirling and Gowan: Architecture from Austerity to Affluence. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Eisenman, Peter. 2015. “Bifurcating Rowe.” In Petit, E. (Ed.) Reckoning with Colin RoweReckoning with Colin Rowe, 56–61. Routledge.

Eisenman, Peter. 2010. “The Rowe Synthesis.” In Marzo, M. (Ed.) L’architettura Come Testo e La Figura Di Colin Row-eL’architettura Come Testo e La Figura Di Colin Rowe, edited by M Marzo, 48–57. Iuav. Documenti. IUAV.

Gordon, D L A. 1997. Battery Park City: Politics and Planning on the New York Waterfront. Amsterdam: Gordon and Breach.

Gottmann, Jean, and Twentieth Century Fund. 1961. Megalopolis: The Urbanized Northeastern Seaboard of the United States. New York: Twentieth Century Fund.

Gibberd, Frederick. 1953. Town Design, Londres: Architectural Press,

Harvey, D. 2005. A Brief History of Neoliberalism. Oxford-New York: OUP Oxford.

Hejduk, J, and K Shkapich. 1985. Mask of Medusa: Works, 1947-1983. New York: Rizzoli. 37-38, 283

Hitchcock, H R. 1947. Painting Toward Architecture. Miller Company Collection of Abstract Art. New Haven – London: Duell, Sloan and Pearce.

Koolhaas, Rem. n.d. “But Most of All, Ungers: Berlin Stories.” In The City in the City: Berlin; A Green Archipelago, (Hertweck, Flori-an; Marot, Sebastien, Eds.), 44–45. Zürich: Lars Müller Publishers.

Koolhaas, Rem. 2015. “Being OMU’s Ghostwriter.” In Reckoning with Colin Rowe, 87–98. Routledge.

Koolhaas, Rem (in conversation with Florian Hertweck and Sébastien Marot). 2013. “Ghostwriting.” In The City in the City: Berlin: A Green Archipelago, 131–43. Zurich: Lars Müller. https://doi.org/LK - https://worldcat.org/title/861576321.

Krier, Rob. 1975. Stadtraum in Theorie Und Praxis. Stuttgart: Kramer.

Marot, Sébastien. 2013. "The Generation of a Hopeful Monster", en Ungers, Oswald Mathias; Koolhaas, Rem, (con) Riemann, Peter; Kollhoff, Hans; Ovaska, Arthur, The City in the City. Berlín: A green archipelago, (Hertweck, Florian; Marot, Sebastien, eds.), Lars Muller Publishers, Zúrich, (1977): 153-61.

Maxwell, Robert. 2010. “Rowe’s Urbanism in Collage City: A Triumph for Common Sense.” In Marzo, M. (Ed.) L’architettura Come Testo et La Figura Di Colin Rowe. Venice: Marsilio Editori, 155–70. Venice: IUAV.

Mazzucco, Katia. 2010. “L’incontro Di Colin Rowe Con Rudolf Wittkower e Un’immagine Del Cosiddetto ‘metodo Warburghiano.” In Marzo, M. (Ed.) L’architettura Come Testo e La Figura Di Colin Rowe, 73–95. Venice: IUAV.

McLeod, Mary. 2013. “T. Dié: A ‘Modern Space Conception’ for Post-War Reconstruction.” In Cohen, Jean Louis (Ed.) Le Corbu-sier: An Atlas of Modern Landscapes, 193–97. New Yok: MoMA.

Mumford, Eric. 2009. Defining Urban Design: CIAM Architects and the Formation of a Discipline. New Haven – London: Yale Uni-versity Press.

Naegele, Daniel (ed.). 2016. The Letters of Colin Rowe: Five Decades of Correspondence. London: Artifice.

Ockman, Joan. 1998. “Form without Utopia: Contextualizing Colin Rowe.” Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 57 (4): 448–56.

Oechslin, Werner. 1985. “Working with Fragments: The Limitations of Collage.” Daidalos, no. 16: 16–30.

Oswald, Franz. 1969. "Buffalo Waterfront", Diagramas: 88. [https://issuu.com/cornellaap/docs/cja002-opt/59]; Rowe, Colin; Seligmann, Werner; Wells, Jerry, "Buffalo Waterfront Project", Catálogo de la exposición, Galería de Arte Albright-Knox, Búfalo (NY).

Peterson Steven; Littenberg, Barbara. 1979. Les Halles Competition Paris, [http://petersonlittenberg.com/Architecture-UrbanDesign/Aims_Means_part_1.html, consultado el 9/12/2018].

Petit, Emmanuel (ed.). 2015. Reckoning with Colin Rowe. Ten Architects Take Position, Nueva York – Abingdon: Routledge, 65-72.

Ponte, Alessandra. 2010. “Woefully Inadequate: Colin Rowe’s Composition and Character.” In Marzo, M. (Ed.) L’architettura Come Testo e La Figura Di Colin Rowe, 30–47. Padua: Marsilio Editori.

Reps, John William. 2021. The Making of Urban America: A History of City Planning in the United States. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Rowe, Colin. 1947. “The Mathematics of the Ideal Villa: Palladio and Le Corbusier Compared.” The Architectural Review CI, no. 603: 101–104.

Rowe, Colin. 1961. “Dominican Monastery of La Tourette, Eveux-Sur-Arbresle, Lyons.” The Architectural Review 772: 400–410.

Rowe, Colin; Jencks, Charles. 1975. “Colin Rowe - In Conversation with Charles Jencks - YouTube.” AA School of Architecture. 1975. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ln_8ymrqgdE.

Rowe, Colin, and Fred Koetter. 1978. Collage City. Cambridge, Mass; London: MIT press.

Rowe, Colin, and Alexander Caragonne (ed.). 1996. Vols 1,2,3. As I Was Saying Series. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.

Rowe, Colin. 1961. “The Blenheim of the Welfare State.” Cambridge Review.

Rowe, Colin, and Robert Slutzky. 1971. “Transparency: Literal and Phenomenal. Part II”. Perspecta, no. 13–14: 287–301.

Saint, Andrew. 2006. “A History of the Architecture Department.” 2006. https://www.arct.cam.ac.uk/aboutthedepartment/aboutthedepthome.

Saxl, Fritz, and Rudolf Wittkower. 1948. British Art and the Mediterranean. (No Title). London: Oxford University Press.

Schrijver, Lara. 2011. “Utopia and/or Spectacle? Rethinking Urban Interventions through the Legacy of Modernism and the Situa-tionist City.” Architectural Theory Review 16 (3): 245–58.

Schumacher, Thomas. 1971. “Contextualism. Urban Ideals and Deformation.” Casabella, no. 359–360: 78–86.

Secchi, Bernardo. 2010. “Collage City.” In L’architettura Come Testo e La Figura Di Colin Rowe Marzo, M. C. (Ed.), 1:146–53. Mila-no: Marsilio Editori.

Semerani, Luciano.2010. "Introduzione a Colin Rowe e all'architettura come testo", en Marzo: 58-71, 12-29

Shane, David Grahame. 1972. Urban Patterns in London. Cornell University.

Shane, David Grahame. 1972. “Contextualism 1; Covent Garden.” Architectural Design 4 (42): 229.

Shane, David Grahame.1976. "Contextualism", Architectural Design, 46 (11), (nov): 676-679.

Shane, Grahame. 1992. “Theory vs Practice”, (Review of Krier’s Book).” Architectural Design II (46): 680–84.

Shane, David Grahame. 2005. Recombinant Urbanism: Conceptual Modelling in Architecture, Urban Design, and City Theory. Chichester, England; Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.

Sitte, C. 1947. City Planning According to Artistic Principles. Columbia University Studies in Art History and Archaeology. New York: Random House.

Soja, E W. 1989. Postmodern Geographies: The Reassertion of Space in Critical Social Theory. Haymarket Series. London: Verso.

Suh, Yehre. 2009. “Rowe X Ungers Exhibition. Untold Collaborations on the City.” Office of / Urban Terrains / Lab Cornell Univer-sity, College of Architecture, Art and Planning, Hartell Gallery, Ithaca, USA Program: Research and Exhibition. 2009. http://urbanterrains.com/project/rowe-x-ungers-exhibition/.

Sunwoo, Irene. 2016. In Progress: The IID Summer Sessions. London: Architectural Association Press.

Vidler, Anthony. 2015. “Reckoning with Art History: Colin Rowe’s Critical Vision.” In Petit, E. (Ed.) Reckoning with Colin Rowe, 40–55. Routledge.

Whinney, Margaret D. 1942. “John Webb’s Drawings for Whitehall Palace.” The Volume of the Walpole Society 31: 45–107.

Wittkower, Rudolf. 1947. “Camillo Sitte’s" Art of Building Cities" in an American Translation.” The Town Planning Review 19 (3/4): 164–69.

Zuccaro Marchi, Leonardo.2017. The Heart of the City: Legacy and Complexity of a Modern Design Idea, London: Routledge. [https://www.academia.edu/34645260/_The_Heart_of_the_City._Legacy_and_Complexity_of_a_Modern_Design_Idea._Foreword_by_Tom_Avermaete_Paola_Viganò._Afterword_by_Vittorio_Gregotti, consultado el 9/12/2018].

Published

2024-09-29

How to Cite

Shane, D. G. (2024). (Dossier Colin Rowe) Notes for an Intellectual Biography of Colin Rowe (1938-78). Astragalo. Culture of Architecture and the City, 1(35), 223 a 276. https://doi.org/10.12795/astragalo.2024.i35.11
Received 2024-05-22
Accepted 2024-05-22
Published 2024-09-29
Views
  • Abstract 110
  • PDF (Esp/Eng/Por) 57