Before “Purity of Blood”. Elements and Metaphors in the 1449-1450 Converso Debate
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12795/PH.2023.v37.i02.05Keywords:
conversos, blood, flesh, purity, honor, lineage, sacraments, race, historiographyAbstract
This study pays careful attention to the ways in which Latin and Castilian terms for ’blood’ and ’flesh’ are employed in the converso debate centered on the anti-converso uprising at Toledo in 1449. It considers how those terms are used —or not used— to conceive of human relationship to one another and to Christ as well as how they convey moral and spiritual status in terms related to purity and impurity. This microscopic look at a particular moment in Castile will enrich telescopic studies that aim for synthesis across disciplinary, chronological, and geographic boundaries. In the more immediate term, this essay demonstrates that, although Iberian historiography has tended to frame the exclusion of conversos from religious and civic life in terms of blood criteria, purity of blood was not a central category in the converso debate of 1449-1450. Rather, the dominant concerns whose relationship to blood and flesh, purity and impurity, faith and heresy, class, king, and country was at stake were honor and lineage itself.
Downloads
References
Amrán Cohén, R. (2006). De Pedro Sarmiento a Martínez Siliceo: La “génesis” de los estatutos de limpieza de sangre. https://www.cervantesvirtual.com/nd/ark:/59851/bmcb2867
Anidjar, G. (2014). Blood: A critique of Christianity. Columbia University Press. https://doi.org/10.7312/anid16720
Benito Ruano, E. (1961). Toledo en el siglo XV: Vida política. Escuela de Estudios Medievales.
Biale, D. (2007). Blood and belief: The circulation of a symbol between Jews and Christians. University of California Press. https://doi.org/10.1525/9780520934238
Burk, R. L. (2010). Salus erat in sanguine: Limpieza de sangre and other discourses of blood in early modern Spain. University of Pennsylvania. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/1550
Bynum, C. W. (2007). Wonderful blood: Theology and practice in late medieval northern Germany and beyond. University of Pennsylvania Press.
Carter, J. K. (2008). Race: A theological account. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195152791.001.0001
Fernández Gallardo, L. (2018). Teología y derecho en el “Defensorium” de Alonso de Cartagena. En J. M. Nieto Soria y Ó. Villarroel González (Eds.), Comunicación y conflicto en la cultura política peninsular: (siglos XIII al XV) (pp. 559-588). Silex.
García-Arenal, M. y Pereda, F. (2021). De sangre y leche: Raza y religión en el mundo ibérico moderno. Marcial Pons Ediciones de Historia.
Guerreau-Jalabert, A. (2013). Flesh and Blood in Medieval Language about Kinship. In C. H. Johnson, B. Jussen, D. W. Sabean, & S. Teuscher (Eds.), Blood and Kinship: Matter for Metaphor from Ancient Rome to the Present (pp. 61-82). Berghahn Books.
Hering Torres, M. S. (2003). “Limpieza de sangre”. ¿Racismo en la edad moderna? Tiempos modernos. Revista electrónica de Historia Moderna, 4(9). http://www.tiemposmodernos.org/tm3/index.php/tm/article/view/26
Hering Torres, M. S. (2012). Purity of blood: Problems of interpretation. In M. S. Hering Torres, M. E. Martínez, & D. Nirenberg (Eds.), Race and blood in the Iberian world (pp. 11-38). LIT Verlag.
Hering Torres, M. S., Martínez, M. E., & Nirenberg, D. (Eds.). (2012). Race and blood in the Iberian world (Vol. 3). LIT Verlag.
Johnson, C. H., Jussen, B., Sabean, D. W., & Teuscher, S. (Eds.). (2013). Blood and kinship: Matter for metaphor from ancient Rome to the present. Berghahn Books.
López Gómez, O. (2014). El impacto de las revueltas urbanas en el siglo XV: A propósito de la rebelión de 1449 en Toledo. Edad Media: revista de historia, (15), 175-191.
Martínez, M. E. (2011). Genealogical fictions: Limpieza de sangre, religion, and gender in colonial Mexico. Stanford University Press.
Moore, R. I. (2007). The Formation of a persecuting society: Authority and deviance in western Europe 950-1250 (2nd ed.). Wiley-Blackwell. https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470773987
Netanyahu, B. (1995). The origins of the Inquisition in fifteenth-century Spain (1st ed.). Random House.
Nirenberg, D. (1996). Communities of violence. Princeton University Press.
Nirenberg, D. (2014). Neighboring faiths: Christianity, Islam, and Judaism in the Middle Ages and today. University of Chicago Press. https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226169095.003.0008
Round, N. G. (1966). La rebelión toledana de 1449: Aspectos ideológicos. Archivum, (16), 385-446.
Sicroff, A. A. (1985). Los estatutos de limpieza de sangre: Controversias entre los siglos XV y XVII. Taurus.
Stuczynski, C. B. (2014). From polemics and apologetics to theology and politics: Alonso de Cartagena and the conversos within the “mystical body.”. In I. Jacob & R. Ben-Shalom (Eds.), Conflict and religious conversation in Latin Christendom: Studies in honour of Ora Limor (pp. 253-275). Brepols. https://doi.org/10.1484/M.CELAMA-EB.1.102017
Stuczynski, C. B. (2020). Converso paulinism and residual Jewishness: Conversion from Judaism to Christianity as a theologico-political problem. In T. Dunkelgrün & P. Maciejko (Eds.), Bastards and Believers (pp. 112-133). University of Pennsylvania Press. https://doi.org/10.9783/9780812296754-007
Teuscher, S. (2013). Flesh and blood in the treatises on the arbor consanguinitas (thirteenth to sixteenth Centuries). In C. H. Johnson, B. Jussen, D. W. Sabean, & S. Teuscher (Eds.), Blood and kinship: Matter for metaphor from ancient Rome to the present (pp. 83-104). Berghahn Books.
Tritle, E. (2015). Anti-Judaism and a hermeneutic of the flesh. Church History and Religious Culture, 95(2-3), 182-202. https://doi.org/10.1163/18712428-09502007
Vidal Doval, R. (2013). ’Nos soli sumus christiani’: Conversos in the texts of the Toledo rebellion of 1449. In A. M. Beresford, J. Weiss, & L. M. Haywood (Eds.), Medieval Hispanic studies in memory of Alan Deyermond (pp. 215-236). Boydell & Brewer.
Vidal Doval, R. (2020). Qui ex iudeis sunt. In M. Garcia-Arenal & Y. Glazer-Eytan (Eds.), Forced Conversion in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam: Coercion and Faith in Premodern Iberia and Beyond (pp. 60-85). Brill.
Primary sources
Barrientos, L. de (2012a). Contra algunos çiçañadores de la nación de los convertidos del pueblo de Israel. In T. González Rolán & P. Saquero Suárez-Somonte (Eds.), De la Sentencia-Estatuto de Pero Sarmiento a la Instrucción del Relator (pp. 121-141). Aben Ezra Ediciones. (Original published in 1449/1450). (Against certain sowers of discord about the nation of those converted from the people of Israel).
Barrientos, L. de (2012b). Respuesta a una proposición. In T. González Rolán & P. Saquero Suárez-Somonte (Eds.), De la Sentencia-Estatuto de Pero Sarmiento a la Instrucción del Relator (pp. 143-191). Aben Ezra Ediciones. (Original published in 1449). (Answer to a proposition).
Carta de privilegio del rey Juan II a un hijodalgo (2012). En T. González Rolán y P. Saquero Suárez-Somonte (Eds.), De la Sentencia-Estatuto de Pero Sarmiento a la Instrucción del Relator (pp. 79-91). Aben Ezra Ediciones. (Original published ca. 1449). (Letter of privilege of the king Juan II to an hidalgo).
Cartagena, A. de (1943). Defensorium unitatis christianae. Tratado en favor de los judíos conversos (P. M. Alonso, Ed.). Consejo superior de investigaciones científicas. (Original published in 1450). (Defense of Christian unity. Treatise in favor of the judeo-conversos).
Cartagena, A. de (forthcoming). Defensorium unitatis christianae (E. Tritle, ed. & trans.). Peeters (original published in 1450).
Díaz de Toledo, F. (2012). Instrucçión del Relator para don Lope de Barrientos, obispo de Cuenca, sobre la çiçaña de Toledo contra Pero Sarmiento y el bachiller Marcos Garçía de Mora. In T. González Rolán & P. Saquero Suárez-Somonte (Eds.), De la Sentencia-Estatuto de Pero Sarmiento a la Instrucción del Relator (pp. 95-120). Aben Ezra Ediciones. (Original published in 1449). (Instruction of the Relator for don Lope de Barrientos, bishop of Cuenca, concerning the discord at Toledo against Pero Sarmiento and the bachelor Marcos García de Mora).
García de Mora, M. (2012). Apelacçión e suplicaçión del bachiller Marcos García de Mora en su favor e de Pero Sarmiento y de esta çibdad de Toledo en tiempo del rey don Juan el segundo. In T. González Rolán & P. Saquero Suárez-Somonte (Eds.), De la Sentencia-Estatuto de Pero Sarmiento a la Instrucción del Relator (pp. 193-242). Aben Ezra Ediciones. (Original published in 1449). (Appeal and supplication of the bachelor Marcos García de Mora in his favor and of Pero Sarmiento and of this city of Toledo in the time of the king don Juan the Second).
Martínez Silíceo, J. (1547). Estatuto de limpieza de la Sagrada Primada Iglesia de las Españas de Toledo. Ms. 6170 Biblioteca Nacional de España. pid bdh0000014024. (Statute of purity of the Holy Primate Church of the Spains of Toledo).
Martínez Silíceo, J. (1701). Papeles referentes al Estatuto de limpieza de sangre de la Iglesia de Toledo, hecho siendo Arzobispo D. Juan Martínez Silíceo. Ms. 13038 Biblioteca Nacional de España. pid bdh0000122705. (Original published in 1547). (Papers in reference to the purity of blood Statute of the Church of Toledo, made by Archbishop D. Juan Martínez Silíceo). http://bdh-rd.bne.es/viewer.vm?id=0000122705&page=1
Sarmiento, P. (2012a). Sentencia-Estatuto de Pedro Sarmiento. En T. González Rolán y P. Saquero Suárez-Somonte (Eds.), De la Sentencia-Estatuto de Pero Sarmiento a la Instrucción del Relator (pp. 13-31). Aben Ezra Ediciones. (Original published in 1449).
Sarmiento, P. (2012b). Suplicación y requirimiento de Pero Sarmiento al rey Juan II. En T. González Rolán y P. Saquero Suárez-Somonte (Eds.), De la Sentencia-Estatuto de Pero Sarmiento a la Instrucción del Relator (pp. 1-12). Aben Ezra Ediciones. (Original published in 1449). (Supplication and request of Pero Sarmiento to the king Juan II).
Torquemada, J. de (2002). Tratado contra los madianitas e ismaelitas, de Juan de Torquemada: Contra la discriminación conversa (C. Del Valle & E. Benito Ruano, ed. & Spanish trans.) Aben Ezra Ediciones. (Original published in 1450). (Treatise against the Midianites and Ishmaelites, by Juan de Torquemada: Against converso discrimination).
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Erika Tritle
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
The printed and electronic editions of this Journal are edited by the University of Seville Editorial, and the source must be cited in any partial or total reproduction.
Unless otherwise indicated, all the contents of the electronic edition are distributed under a license of use and distribution “Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International” . You can view the informative version and the legal text of the license here. This fact must be expressly stated in this way when necessary.
Authors who publish in this journal accept the following conditions:
- The author/s retain copyright and grant the journal the first publication right, and accept it to be distributed with the Creative Commons By NC ND 4.0 licence, which allows third parties to use what is published whenever they mention the authorship of the work and the first publication in this journal and whenever they do not make commercial use and reuse it in the same way.
- Authors can make other independent and additional contractual agreements for the non-exclusive distribution of the article published in this journal (e.g., include it in an institutional repository or publish it in a book) provided they clearly indicate that the work was published for the first time in this journal.
Authors are allowed and recommended, once the article has been published in the journal Philologia Hispalensis (online version), to download the corresponding PDF and disseminate it online (ResearchGate, Academia.edu, etc.) as it may lead to productive scientific exchanges and to a greater and faster dissemination of published work (see The Effect of Open Access).
Accepted 2023-04-05
Published 2023-12-15
- Abstract 141
- PDF 92
- HTML 58
- XML 26
