Spanish subjects can be subjects: Acquisitional and empirical evidence
Keywords:
Overt subjects, left periphery, wh-questions, dislocations, acquisitionAbstract
The paper provides novel converging acquisitional and empirical evidence from Spanish in support of the hypothesis that preverbal subjects in Spanish can, but need not, be left-dislocated constituents in the CP layer; they can occupy the canonical subject position, Spec,TP, contrary to what is often assumed in the literature. On the basis of acquisitional and statistical evidence gathered from a longitudinal study of five children, the paper argues against Grinstead’s (1998 et seq.) claim that overt subjects emerge in development concurrently with less controversially CP-related phenomena such as wh-questions and dislocations. Moreover, based on the different distributional behavior of genuine subjects and dislocations/foci in the context of desiderative/exhortative sentences introduced by que ‘that,’ the paper argues that Spec,TP/AgrSP is indeed available in Spanish and can only host bona fide subjects to the exclusion of non-subject XPs.
Downloads
References
Aguado-Orea, Javier & Pine, Julián. 2002. There is no evidence for a 'ʹno overt subject'ʹ stage in early child Spanish: a note on Grinstead (2000). Journal of Child Language 29, 865-874.
Aguirre, Carmen. 1995. La adquisición de las categorías gramaticales en español. Doctoral dissertation, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid.
Alexiadou, Artemis & Elena Anagnostopoulou. 1998. Parameterizing AGR: Word Order, V-Movement and EPP-Checking. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 16, 491-539.
Austin, Jennifer, María Blume, David Parkinson, Barbara C. Lust & Zelmira Núñez del Prado. 1997. The Status of Pro-Drop in the Initial State. In Ana Teresa Pérez-Leroux & William Glass (eds.), Contemporary Perspectives on the Acquisition of Spanish. 37-54. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Press.
Baker, Mark. 1996. The Polysynthesis Parameter. New York: Oxford University Press.
Barbosa, Pilar. 1995. Null Subjects. Doctoral dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, MA.
Barbosa, Pilar. 2000. Clitics: a window into the null subject property. In João Costa (ed.), Portuguese Syntax. New Comparative Studies. 31-94. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Barbosa, Pilar. 2009. Two Kinds of Subject pro. Studia Linguistica 63, 2-58.
Beas, Omar. 2007. Agreement on the Left Edge and the Syntax of Dislocation in
Spanish. Doctoral dissertation, University of Southern California.
Bel, Aurora. 2001. Sujetos nulos y sujetos explícitos en las gramáticas iniciales
del castellano y el catalán. Revista Española de Lingüística, 31, 537-562.
Bel, Aurora. 2003. The syntax of subjects in the acquisition of Spanish and
Catalan. Probus 15, 1-26.
Belletti, Adriana. 1988. The Case of Unaccusatives. Linguistic Inquiry 19, 1-34.
Belletti, Adriana. 2004. Aspects of the low IP area. In Luigi Rizzi (ed.), The Structure of IP and CP. The Cartography of Syntactic Structures (vol.2.). 16- 51. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Camacho, José. 2006. Do Subjects have a Place in Spanish? In Jean-Pierre Montreuil & Chiyo Nishida (eds.), New Perspectives in Romance Linguistics. 51-66. Amsterdam-Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Camacho, José. 2011. On the position of preverbal subject in Spanish. A view from the discourse perspective, ms, Rutgers University.
Cardinaletti, Anna. 1996. Subjects and clause structure. University of Venice Working Papers in Linguistics 6, 55–95.
Cardinaletti, Anna. 2004. Toward a cartography of subject positions. In Luigi Rizzi (ed.), The structure of CP and IP. The Cartography of Syntactic Structures (vol. 2). 115-165. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.
Casielles, Eugenia. 2001. The Syntax and Semantics of Preverbal Topical Phrases in Spanish. In Javier Gutiérrez-Rexach & Luis Silva-Villar (eds.), Current Issues in Spanish Syntax and Semantics. 65-82. Berlin/New York: Mouton DeGruyter.
Cinque, Guglielmo. 1990. Types of Ā-dependencies. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Contreras, Heles. 1991. On the position of subjects. Syntax and Semantics 25, 63– 79.
Costa, João. 2004. Subject Positions and Interfaces: The Case of European Portuguese. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
D’Alessandro, Roberta & Adam Ledgeway. 2010. At the C-T boundary: Investigating Abruzzese complementation. Lingua 120, 2040-2060.
Demonte, Violeta & Olga Fernández-Soriano 2007. La periferia izquierda oracional y los complementantes del español. In Juan Cuartero & Martine Emsel (eds.), Vernetzungen: Kognition, Bedeutung, (kontrastive) Pragmatik. Frankfurt: Peter Lang.
Demonte, Violeta & Olga Fernández-Soriano. 2009. Force and finiteness in the Spanish complementizer system. Probus 21, 23–49.
Demonte, Violeta & Olga Fernández-Soriano. In press. El 'ʹque'ʹ citativo en español y otros elementos de la periferia oracional. Variación inter e intralingüística. In Daniel Jakob & Katya Plooj (eds.), Autour de ‘que’. Frankfurt: Peter Lang.
Dobrovie-Sorin, Carmen. 1994. The Syntax of Romanian: Comparative Studies in Romance. Dordrecht: Foris.
Emonds, Joe. 1978. The Verbal Complex V’-V in French. Linguistic Inquiry 9, 151- 176.
Etxepare, Ricardo & Myriam Uribe-Etxebarria. 2008. On Negation and Focus in Spanish and Basque. In Xabier Artiagoitia & Joseba Lakarra (eds.), Gramatika Jaietan: Patxi Goenaga irakaslearenOmenaldiz. Special issue of International Journal of Basque Linguistics and Philology. 287-310.
Etxepare, Ricardo. 2010. From hearsay evidentiality to samesaying relations. Lingua 120, 604-627.
Fontana, Josep M. 1993. Phrase structure and the syntax of clitics in the history of Spanish. Doctoral dissertation, University of Pennsylvania.
Gallego, Ángel. 2007. Phase theory and parametric variation. Doctoral dissertation, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona.
Goodall, Grant. 2001. The EPP in Spanish. In William Davies & Stanley Dubinsky (eds.), Objects and Other Subjects: Grammatical Functions, Functional Categories, and Configurationality. 193-223. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Grinstead, John & Patti Spinner. 2009. The clausal left periphery in child
Spanish and German. Probus 21, 51-82.
Grinstead, John. 1998. Subjects, sentential negation, and imperatives in child Spanish
and Catalan, Doctoral dissertation, UCLA.
Grinstead, John. 2000. Tense, Number and Nominative Case Assignment in
Child Catalan and Spanish. Journal of Child Language 27, 119-155. Grinstead, John. 2004. Subjects and Interface Delay in Child Spanish and
Catalan. Language 80, 40-72.
Gupton, Timothy. 2010. The Syntax Information Structure Interface: Subjects and
Clausal Word Order in Galician. Doctoral dissertation, University of Iowa. Gupton, Timothy. To appear. Preverbal Subjects in Galician: Experimental Data
in the A vs. Ā Debate. Probus.
Holmberg, Anders. 2005. Is there a little pro? Evidence from Finnish. Linguistic
Inquiry 36, 533-564.
Kapetangianni, Konstantia. 2010. Variable word order in child Greek. In Merete Anderssen, Kristine Bentzen & Marit Westergaard (eds.), Variation in the Input. 179-204. Dordrecht: Springe.
Kato, Mary. 1999. Strong pronouns and weak pronominals in the null subject parameter. Probus 11, 1-37.
Kempchinsky, Paula. 2002. Locative Inversion, PP Topicalization, and the EPP. In Teresa Satterfield, Christina Tortora & Diana Cresti (eds.), Current Issues in Romance Languages. 145-159. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Laka, Itziar. 1990. Negation in syntax, Doctoral dissertation, MIT.
Ledgeway, Adam. 2005. Moving through the left periphery: the dual complementizer system in the dialects of Southern Italy. Philological
Society 103, 229-396.
López, Luis. 2009. A Derivational Syntax for Information Structure. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
MacWhinney, Brian. 2000. Guide to CHILDES data on the acquisition of Romance
languages. Mahwah, NH: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Manzini, Rita & Leonardo M. Savoia. 2002. Parameters of Subject Inflection in Italian Dialects. In Peter Svenonious (ed.), Subjects, Expletives, and the EPP. 157-200. New York: Oxford University Press.
Martín-González, Javier. 2002. The Syntax of sentential negation in Spanish. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.
Masullo, Pascual. 1992. Incorporation and Case Theory in Spanish: A Crosslinguistic Perspective. Doctoral dissertation, University of Washington.
Motapanyane-Hill, Virginia. 1991. Theoretical Implications of the Complementation in Romanian, Doctoral dissertation, University of Genève.
Ojea, Ana. 1997. Categorías funcionales y adquisición de la primera lengua: Un análisis contrastivo. In Revista Española de Lingüística 27, 425-446.
Olarrea, Antxon. 1996. Pre and Postverbal Subjects in Spanish: A Minimalist Account. Doctoral dissertation, University of Washington.
Ordóñez, Francisco & Esthela Treviño. 1999. Left dislocated subjects and the pro-drop parameter: A case study of Spanish. Lingua 107, 39-68.
Ordóñez, Francisco. 1997. Word Order and Clausal Structure of Spanish and Other Romance Languages. Doctoral dissertation, CUNY.
Ortega-Santos, Iván. 2005. On Locative Inversion and the EPP in Spanish. Actas del VIII Encuentro Internacional de Lingüística del Noroeste de la Universidad de Sonora. 131-150. Universidad de Sonora, México.
Ortega-Santos, Iván. 2006. On Postverbal Subjects, PF and the Copy Theory: The Spanish Case. In Nuria Sagarra & Almeida Jacqueline Toribio (eds.), Selected Proceedings of the 9th Hispanic Linguistics Symposium. 56-66. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.
Ortega-Santos, Iván. 2008. Projecting Subjects in English and Spanish. Doctoral dissertation, University of Maryland-College Park.
Otero, Carlos. 1993. Head Movement, Cliticization, and Word Insertion. In Robert Freidin (ed.), Current Issues in Comparative Grammar. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Paoli, Sandra. 2003. COMP and the left periphery: Comparative Evidence from Romance. Doctoral dissertation, University of Manchester.
Paoli, Sandra. 2006. The fine structure of the left periphery: COMPs and subjects: evidence from Romance. Lingua 117, 1057-1079.
Philippaki-Warburton, Irene. 1985. Word order in Modern Greek. Transactions of the Philological Society, 113-143.
Poeppel, David & Kenneth Wexler. 1993. The full competence hypothesis.
Language 60, 1-33.
Pollock, Yean-Yves. 1989. Verb Movement, Universal Grammar, and the
Structure of IP. Linguistic Inquiry 20, 365-424.
RAE. 2009. Nueva Gramática de la Lengua Española. Real Academia Española
(RAE). Madrid: Espasa.
Rizzi, Luigi. 1982. Issues in Italian Syntax. Dordrecht: Foris.
Rizzi, Luigi. 1997. The fine structure of the left periphery. In Liliane Haegeman (ed.), Elements of Grammar. 281-337. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Rizzi, Luigi. 2001. On the position “Int(errogative)” in the left periphery of the clause. In Guglielmo Cinque & Giampaolo Salvi (eds.), Current Studies in Italian Syntax. Essays Offered to Lorenzo Renzi. 287–296. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Rizzi, Luigi. 2004. Locality and Left Periphery. In Adriana Belletti (ed.), Structures and Beyond: The Cartography of Syntactic Structures, vol.3, 223- 225. Oxford University Press.
Rodríguez-Mondoñedo, Miguel. 2007. The Syntax of Objects: Agree and Differential Object Marking, Doctoral dissertation, University of Connecticut, Storrs.
Ron, María Pilar. 1998. The Position of the Subject in Spanish and Clausal Structure: Evidence from Dialectal Variation. Doctoral dissertation, Northwestern University, Illinois.
Roussou, Anna & Ianthi-Maria Tsimpli. 2006. On Greek VSO again. Journal of Linguistics 42, 317-354.
Roussou, Anna. 2000. On the left periphery: Modal particles and complementizers. Journal of Greek Linguistics 1, 65-94.
Schaeffer, Jeannette. 2000. The Acquisition of Direct Object Scrambling and Clitic Placement. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Snyder, William & Karin Stromswold. 1997. The structure and acquisition of English dative constructions. Linguistic Inquiry 28, 281-317.
Snyder, William. 2007. Child Language: The Parametric Approach. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Solà, Jaume. 1992. Agreement and Subjects, Doctoral dissertation, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona.
Speas, Margaret. 1994. Null Arguments in a Theory of Economy of Projection. In Elena Benedicto & Jeff Runner (eds.), UMass Occasional Papers in Linguistics 17, 179-209.
Spinner, Patti & John Grinstead. 2006. Subjects, Topicalizations and Wh- Questions in Child German and Southern Romance. In Nuria Sagarra & Almeida Jacqueline Toribio (eds.), Selected Proceedings of the 9th Hispanic Linguistic Symposium. 241-251. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Press.
Spyropoulos, Vassilios & Anthi Revithiadou. 2009. Subject chains in Greek and PF processing. In Claire Halpert, Jeremy Hartman & David Hill (eds.), Proceedings of the 2007 workshop in Greek syntax and semantics at MIT. Cambridge, MA: MWPL, 293-309.
Stromswold, Karin. 1996. Analyzing children'ʹs spontaneous speech. In Dana McDaniel, Cecile McKee & Helen Smith-Cairns (eds.), Methods for assessing children'ʹs syntax. 22-53. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Suñer, Margarita. 2003. The Lexical Preverbal Subject in a Romance Null Subject Language: Where Art Thou? In Rafael Núñez-Cedeño et al. (eds.), A romance perspective on language knowledge and use. 341-357. Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Taraldsen, Knut. 1992. Subject/Verb-Agreement in Celtic and Romance. Proceedings of NELS, GLSA, Amherst.
Ticio, Emma. 2004. On the position of subjects in Puerto Rican Spanish. In Miguel Rodríguez-Mondoñedo & Emma Ticio (eds.), The University of Connecticut Working Papers in Linguistics (UCONNWPL) 12, 78-92.
Torrego, Esther. 1984. On Inversion in Spanish and Some of Its Effects. Linguistic Inquiry 15, 103-129.
Torrego, Esther. 1989. Unergative unaccusative alternations. MIT Working Papers in Linguistics 10, 253-272.
Uriagereka, Juan. 1999. Multiple Spell-Out. In Samuel Epstein & Norbert Hornstein (eds.), Working Minimalism. 251-282. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Uribe-Etxebarria, Myriam. 1992. On the Structural Positions of the Subject in Spanish, their Nature and their Consequences for Quantification. In Joseba Lakarra and Jon Ortiz de Urbina (eds.), Studies in Generative Grammar and Basque Syntax. International Journal of Basque Linguistics and Philosophy, 447-491.
Vila, Ignasi. 1984. La competencia comunicativa en los dos primeros años de vida. Doctoral dissertation, Universidad de Barcelona.
Villa-García, Julio & William Snyder. 2010. On the acquisition of overt subjects, topics and wh-questions in Spanish. In JoãoCosta, María Lobo & Fernanda Pratas (eds.), Language Acquisition and Development: Proceedings of GALA 2009. 493-504.Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Villa-García, Julio. 2011. Acquisitional Evidence Bearing on the Account of Preverbal and Postverbal Subjects in Spanish. In Luis Ortiz (ed.), Selected Proceedings of the 13th Hispanic Linguistics Symposium. 178-189. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Press.
Villa-García, Julio. 2012a. Characterizing Medial and Low Complementizers in Spanish: Recomplementation Que and ‘Jussive/Optative’ Que. In Melvin González-Rivera & Sandro Sessarego (eds.), Current Formal Aspects of Spanish Syntax and Semantics. 198-228. Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Villa-García, Julio. 2012b. The Spanish Complementizer System: Consequences for the Syntax of Dislocations and Subjects, Locality of Movement, and Clausal Structure. Doctoral dissertation, University of Connecticut, Storrs.
Villa-García, Julio. 2012c. Recomplementation and locality of movement in Spanish. Probus 24 (2), 257-314.
Villa-García, Julio. To appear. On the Role of Children’s Deterministic Learning in the ‘No-Overt-Subject’ Stage in the L1 Acquisition of Spanish. In Proceedings of the 37th Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society.
Yang, Charles. 2011. Three factors in language variation. In Anna Maria Di Sciullu & Cedric Boeckx (eds.), The Biolinguistic Enterprise: New Perspectives on the Evolution and Nature of the Human Language Faculty. 181-204. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Zubizarreta, María Luisa. 1998. Word Order, Prosody and Focus. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Zubizarreta, María Luisa. 1999. Word order in Spanish and the nature of nominative Case. In Kyle Johnson & Ian Roberts (eds.), Beyond Principles and Parameters. 223-250. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Downloads
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Las ediciones impresa y electrónica de esta Revista son editadas por el Secretariado de Publicaciones de la Universidad de Sevilla, siendo necesario citar la procedencia en cualquier reproducción parcial o total.Salvo indicación contraria, todos los contenidos de la edición electrónica se distribuyen bajo una licencia de uso y distribución “Creative Commons Atribución-NoComercial-SinDerivar 4.0 Internacional”
. Puede consultar desde aquí la versión informativa y el texto legal de la licencia. Esta circunstancia ha de hacerse constar expresamente de esta forma cuando sea necesario.
