Postsionismos, Neosionismos y revisión de las dinámicas del Estado de Israel: Post-Zionisms, Neo-Zionisms and the revision of the dynamics of the Israeli state

Carmen Lopez Alonso

doi:10.12795/araucaria.2025.i59.11

Autores/as

Carmen Lopez Alonso Universidad Complutense

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.12795/araucaria.2025.i59.11

Palabras clave:

Sionismo, postsionismo, neosionismo, nuevo-sionismo, identidad judía, Estado de Israel, conflicto israelo-palestino.

Resumen

Este artículo examina el proceso de revisión-reforma del sionismo y del Estado de Israel, especialmente tras los cambios políticos y sociológico de la década de 1970. Dos líneas pluridimensionales caracterizan ese proceso. Por un lado, las calificadas como postsionistas, por otro, el llamado neosionismo, que debe ser diferenciado del nuevo-sionismo. Se exponen sus puntos de coincidencia y sus diferencias, en política, religión, identidad judía, etc. El impacto del ataque del 7 de octubre de 2023 perpetrado por Hamas y la subsiguiente guerra de Gaza es todavía un capítulo abierto.

Descargas

Los datos de descargas todavía no están disponibles.

Citas

Abu-Tarbush &. Barreñada 2023. J.Abu-Tarbush & I. Barreñada, Palestina. De los Acuerdos de Oslo al apartheid. Catarata. (Madrid, 2023)

ADALAH: https://www.adalah.org/

Aderet 2025. O. Aderet, “The Zionist Dream in Essence': The History of the Palestinian Transfer Debate, Explained' Haaretz (12/02/2025) https://goo.su/FxUk

Avishai 2018. B. Avishai, “Confederation: The One Possible Israel-Palestine Solution” NYRB 2/2/2018. https://goo.su/BsDg

Basallote 2022. A. Basallote, “El postsionismo y la cuestión palestina-israelí. Fisuras, reacciones y continuidad” Anaquel estudios árabes 33 (2022): 143-174

Barreñada 2004. I. Barreñada, Identidad nacional y ciudadanía en el conflicto israelo palestino. Tesis doctoral. Madrid. Univ. Complutense

Baron 1928. S.W. Baron, «Ghetto and Emancipation: ¿Shall We Revise the Traditional View? » Menorah Journal 14 (1928): 515.

BDS, https://bdsmovement.net/

Becke 2021. J.Becke. “Post-Zionism and Israel”. En Kumaraswamy, P.R. (eds) The Palgrave International Handbook of Israel. Palgrave Macmillan. (N.York, 2021) https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-16-2717-0_22-1

Beilin &Husseini 2022. Y. Beilin & H.Husseini. The Holy Land Confederation as a Facilitator for the Two-State Solution. https://ecf.org.il/media_items/1538

———. 2025, Iniciativa de Berlín https://goo.su/CukVwuG

Beinart 2025. P. Beinart. Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza. A Reckoning (N.York, 2025): Knopf

Beinin 2005. J.Beinin, "Forgetfulness for Memory: The Limits of the New Israeli History." Journal of Palestine Studies 34, no. 2: 6-23.

Berent 2010. M. Berent, “The ethnic democracy debate: how unique is Israel?” Nations and Nationalism Vol. 16 pgs. 657-674.

Boyarin 2023. D. Boyarin, The No-state Solution: A Jewish manifesto Yale University Press

Boyarin & Boyarin 1993. D. Boyarin & J. Boyarin, "Diaspora: Generation and the Ground of Jewish Identity." Critical Inquiry 19, no. 4 : 693-725.

Bravo, 2024. F. Bravo. ¿Qué está pasando con el antisemitismo? Revista de libros, 25/9/2024

Bresheeth-Žabner 2020. H.Bresheeth-Žabner, An Army like No Other. How the Israel Defense Forces Made a Nation. (London, 2020)

Butler, 2012. J. Butler. Parting ways: Jewishness and the critique of Zionism. (N. York, 2012)

Caplan, 2019. N. Caplan, The Israel‐Palestine conflict: contested histories (N.York, 2019)

CBS, Central Bureau of Statistics (www.cbs.gov.il)

Chazan 2021. N. Chazan, “Occupation and Israeli Democracy”. The Palgrave International Handbook of Israel pp 1–38. (N. York 2021)

Daniel 2005. J. Daniel. La prison juive. (Paris, 2005)

Declaración de Jerusalén https://jerusalemdeclaration.org/

Dieckhoff 2023. A. Dieckhoff, “Israel: la extrema derecha y los ultraortodoxos en posición dominante”. Afkar Ideas, no.68 https://goo.su/0JsmWuq

Eisenstadt 2002 [1997]. S.N.Eisenstadt Le retour des juifs dans l'Histoire ( Bruselas, 2002).

Eldar, & Zertal 2007. A. Eldar & I. Zertal, Lords of the Land: The War for Israel's Settlements in the Occupied Territories 1967-2007. (N. York, 2007)

Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2007. (Detroit, Jerusalem, 2007)

Fadel 2024. M. Fadel, “Beyond Liberal Zionism: International Law, Political Liberalism, and the Possibility of a Just Zionism”, Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems, vol, 34.1

Fiedler 2017. L.Fiedler. “Israel in Revolution. Matzpen, the Palestine Conflict, and the Hebrew Nation” Israel Studies, 22(3), 153-176.

Freeden 1986. M. Freeden, The New Liberalism: an ideology of Social Reform (Oxford, 1986).

Friesel & Schwarz-Friesel 2023. E. Friesel & M. Schwarz-Friesel “The Israelization of Jew-hatred and the concept 'antisemitism-light' “Israel Affairs Vol. 29 no.1 Pag. 107-119

Friling 2004. T. Friling, ed. Critique du post-sionisme: réponse aux nouveaux historiens israéliens. (Paris, 2004)

Ganim 1998. A. Ganim, N.N. Rouhana & O. Yiftachel. "Questioning "Ethnic Democracy": A Response to Sammy Smooha." Israel Studies 3, no. 2: 253-267.

Gavison 2018, R. Gavison, “Israel’s Nation-State Law and the three circles of solidarity: a round table with Ruth Gavison”, Fathom Journal, Sept.

———, 1999. “Jewish and Democratic? A Rejoinder to the "Ethnic Democracy" Debate” Israel Studies 4.1pgs. 44-72

Gelber 2011. Y. Gelber. Nation and history: Israeli historiography between Zionism and post-Zionism. (Portland, 2011)

Gellman 2017. U. Gellman “The State of Israel: Haven in Zion” en David Biale & all, Hasidim: A New History. (cp. 28, pgs.:707-738), (Princeton,2017).

Ghanim 2021. H. Ghanim, “Israel's Nation-State Law. Hierarchized Citizenship and Jewish Supremacy” Critical Times. 4, 3, pgs. 565-576.

Gitelman 2003: Z.Gitelman (Ed.) The emergence of modern Jewish politics: Bundism and Zionism in Eastern Europe. (Pittsbugh 2003)

Golan 2025, Y. Golan “Our Zionism Is Not One of Mass Displacement and Eternal War, It’s of Equality and Freedom”, https://goo.su/eXuWpn

Goldstein & Shilo 2022. A.Goldstein & E. Shilo, “Generational crossover: ‘the Movement for the Entire Land of Israel’ from the Labour movement to Gush Emunim”. Israel Affairs, 28 (1): 45-59.

Gorny 2006. J. Gorny. Converging Alternatives. The Bund and the Zionist Labor Movement,1897–1985. ( N. York 2006)

Greenstein, 2014. R. Greenstein, Zionism and its discontents. A Century of Radical Dissent in Israel/Palestine. (London, 2014)

———, 2009. “Class, Nation, and Political Organization: The Anti-Zionist Left in Israel/Palestine” International Labor and Working-Class History .75 (1): 85-108

Greilsammer 1998. I. Greilsammer, La nouvelle histoire d'Israel. Essai sur une identité nationale. (Paris, 1998)

Grinberg 2008. L. Grinberg. “El ‘régimen dual’ en Israel desde 1967” Araucaria, 10 (19).

Hazony 2018. Y.Hazony, The virtue of nationalism (N. York, 2018)

——— 2000. The Jewish State: The Struggle for Israel's Soul. (N. York, 2000

——— 1997, “The Jewish State at 100” Azure, Spring 5757: 17-49.

Horowitz & Lissak 1989. D. Horowitz & M. Lissak, Trouble in Utopia: the overburdened polity of Israel (N. York, 1989)

Inbari 2012. M. Inbari, Christian Zionism in the Twenty-First Century. American Evangelical Opinion on Israel. (N. York, 2012).

Inbari & Bumin 2023. M. Inbari & K.Bumin. Christian Zionism in the Twenty-First Century_ American Evangelical Opinion on Israel, (Oxford, 2023)

ICG 2024, International Crisis Group, Stemming Israeli Settler Violence at Its Root https://goo.su/I7a1Vv

IDI, Israel Democracy Institute, https://en.idi.org.il

IHRA, https://holocaustremembrance.com

Jabotinsky 1941 (1923). W. Jabotinsky, “The Ethics of the Iron Wall”. The Jewish Standard. (Original en Rassvyet (Paris, 11/11/1923)

Kaplan 2015. E. Kaplan. Beyond Post-Zionism (N. York, 2015)

——— 2005. The Jewish radical right: Revisionist Zionism and its ideological legacy. (Wisconsin, 2005)

Karsh 1997. E. Karsh, Fabricating Israeli History: The New Historians, (London, 1997)

Katz & Gidron 2021. G.Katz & B. Gidron, “Encroachment and Reaction of Civil Society in Non-liberal Democracies: The Case of Israel and the New Israel Fund” Nonprofit Policy Forum Vol. 13

Kimmerling 2008. B. Kimmerling, Clash of Identities: explorations in Israeli and Palestinian societies. (N. York, 2008).

——— 2004. “Benny Morris’s Shocking Interview” https://goo.su/b2xAf

———.1983. Zionism and territory: the socio-territorial dimensions of Zionist politics Institute of International Studies (Berkeley, 1983)

Kook, 2003. Rabbi A.I. H. Kook. When God Becomes History. Historical Essays of Rabbi Abraham Isaac Hakohen Kook (Edición de Bezalel Naor). (Spring Valley, NY: 2003).

Lehmann & Siebzehner 2019. D. Lehmann & B. Siebzehner. “The Past, Present and Future of Shas” Tel Aviv Review of Books, Fall.

——— 2006. Remaking of Israeli Judaism: The Challenge of Shas. London (2006)

Leifer 2024. J.Leifer. Tablets Shattered: The End of an American Jewish Century and the Future of Jewish Life. N. York: Dutton.

Leon 2022. N. Leon, Guardians of Jewish tradition: from crisis to rehabilitation in the Shas party, 2019-21. Israel affairs, Vol.28 (6) :840-855

Lerman, 2022. A. Lerman Whatever happened to antisemitism? Redefinition and the myth of the ‘collective Jew’ (London, 2022).

Leibowitz, 1992. Y. Leibowitz, Judaism, Human Values and the Jewish State. (Cambridge:MS, 1992).

López Alonso, 2025. C. López Alonso “Conocimiento, Reconocimiento, Reconciliación. Caminos posibles en Israel y Palestina” en Israel y Palestina: reflexiones sobre el futuro y el legado de Oslo, (Madrid, 2025: 163-181).

———. 2024, “Justicia y memoria en Palestina. La Nakba como proceso no cerrado”, en I. Barreñada & L. Thieux (eds) La cuestión Palestina. Colonialismo, Nakba, ocupación y genocidio, (Madrid, 2024: 61-79).

———. 2022, ¿Caminando sobre un volcán? Religión y política en Israel: la utilización del texto bíblico como argumento. Ilu. Revista de Ciencias de las Religiones, 27 (e81648), doi: https://dx.doi.org/10.5209/ilur.81468

———. 2021, “Víctimas y victimización colectiva en conflictos de larga duración. El papel de la historia: el caso de Israel-Palestina” Historia del Presente, 38 (2): 89-106

———. 2009, “Historia y presente en Israel y Palestina. Separación, oposición y entrecruzamiento de dos historias paralelas. Nuevos y viejos enfoques”. Ayer. Revista de Historia Contemporánea. 76 (4): 293-317

———. 2008, “Religión y Política en Israel” Claves de Razón Práctica.183: 66-73

———. 2000, “Israel, ¿Nación-laboratorio?” en Ismael Saz y M.V. Romeo (ed). El siglo XX: balance y perspectivas (Valencia, 2000)..

Lynch & Telhami, 2024. M.Lynch & S. Telhami, The Two-State Mirage, Foreign Affairs (Feb. 20) https://goo.su/HpPc0

Lustick (ed.) 1988. I.Lustick. For the Land and the Lord. Jewish Fundamentalism in Israel Council Foreign Relations

Magid, 2023. S. Magid. The Necessity of Exile. Essays from a Distance. (N.York, 2023)

———, 2021. Meir Kahane: The Public Life and Political Thought of an American Jewish Radical. (Princeton, 2021).

Masalha, 2014 [2013]. Nur Masalha. The Zionist Bible: Biblical Precedent, Colonialism and the Erasure of Memory. (N. York, 2014).

McDermott (ed) 2016. G.R. McDermott, The New Christian Zionism: Fresh Perspectives on Israel and the Land. IVP Academic.

Metzer1998. J. Metzer, The Divided Economy of Mandatory Palestine, (Cambridge: 1998).

Minczeles, 1995. H. Minczeles. Histoire Générale du Bund un Mouvement Révolutionnaire Juif. (Paris 1995)

Mittleman, 1996. A. Mittleman. The politics of Torah: The Jewish political tradition and the founding of Agudat Israel (N. York , 1996)

Morris, 2008; B. Morris, 1948: A History of the First Arab Israeli War. (New Haven, 2008).

———, 2007, ed. Making Israel. (Michigan: Ann Arbor, 2007).

———, 2004, “Survival of the Fitest” Haaretz, 8 January

———, 2001 Righteous Victims. A History of the Zionist-Arab Conflict, 1881-2001. (N. York, 2001)

———,1988 "The New Historiography: Israel confronts its past." Tikkun Nov-Dec (1988): 19-23/99-102 (reimpreso varias veces).

Newman, 2012. David Newman “Gush Emunim and the settler movement” en Peters, J., & Newman, D. (Eds.). (2012). Routledge handbook on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. (N.York, 2012:256-266

Nimni, 2003. E.Nimni (ed). The challenge of post-Zionism: alternatives to Israeli fundamentalist politics (London, New York, 2003).

Pappe, 2024. I.Pappe, A Very Short History of the Israel–Palestine Conflict (London, 2024).

———, 2024, “Afterword: 7 October and the Future”, en Lobbying for Zionism on Both Sides of the Atlantic. (N. York, 2024).

———, 2024 a The Collapse of Zionism. New Left Review https://goo.su/qetKzUq

———, 2006. The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine. (N. York, 2006)

———, 1997 Post-Zionist Critique on Israel and the Palestinians (Parts I, II, III) Journal of Palestine Studies (26,2: 29-41; 26,3: 37-43; 26,4 :60-69)

PEW, 2021, https://goo.su/x40DTB

Pianko 2010, N.Pianko. Zionism and the roads not taken. Rawidowicz, Kaplan, Kohn. (Bloomington,2010)

Pinsker 1882: L.Pinsker "Autoemancipation!”: Mahnruf an seine Stammesgenossen. Commissions-Verlag von W. Issleib,, https://goo.su/oGoeH

Prior 2005 [1999]. M. Prior, Zionism and the State of Israel: A Moral Inquiry. N York 2005).

Ram 2018. U. Ram Israeli Sociology. Text in Context. (N. York, 2018)

———, 2011. Israeli Nationalism. Social conflicts and the politics of knowledge (N. York, 2011).

———, 2005, “Post-Zionist Studies of Israel. The First Decade”. Israel Studies Forum 20. 2, pp. 22-45

Ramos 2021. J. Ramos Tolosa ¿Por qué Palestina-Israel es una cuestión de colonialismo de asentamiento? Ayer 124 (4): 135-161

———, 2020, “La historiografía revisionista israelí: terremoto, giro y declive” Revista de Paz y Conflictos Pags. 53-78

Raz-Krakotzkin 2007. A. Raz-Krakotzkin. Exil et souveraineté : judaïsme, sionisme et pensée binationale. (Paris: 2007).

Rogan & Shlaim 2001; E. L. Rogan & A. Shlaim, eds. The War for Palestine. Rewriting the History of 1948. (Cambridge, 2001).

Sánchez 2022. S. Sánchez, “La organización y transformación de las redes de poder en Israel y su impacto en la estructura internacional”. Tesis de Doctorado. Universidad Complutense. https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/tesis?codigo=323975

Scham 2025. P. Scham. “Where we are and where we need to be”. https://goo.su/hUnZ3U

Setter 2023. S. Setter, “The Return to Exile: Critical Shifts in the Age of Neo-Zionism”. En Branciforte & McGlazer&Ramsey (Ed.), Reaction Formations: The Subject of Ethnonationalism. (N. York, 2023: 155).

Shabi 2024. R. Shabi Off-White: The Truth About Antisemitism. (N. York, 2024).

Shafir 2017. G. Shafir, A half century of occupation: Israel, Palestine, and the world's most intractable conflict (OaklaOakland, nd, 2017)

———.1996 [1989] Land, Labor and the Origins of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, 1882-1914. (Oakland, 1996) (2ª ed).

Shapira & Penslar (2013 [2003]), A.Shapira & D. Penslar. Israeli Historical Revisionism: From Left to Right (N. York, 2013)

Shenhav, 2006. Yehuda Shenhav. The Arab Jews: a postcolonial reading of nationalism, religion, and ethnicity (Yehudim-ha-'Arvim) Stanford University Press

Shlaim 2023, A. Shlaim, Three Worlds. Memoirs of an Arab-Jew. (London, 2023).

———. (2014, [2000]) The Iron Wall, Israel and the Arab World. (Hay traducción española. El muro de hierro. Granada, 2003) (N. York, 2014).

———. 1988. Collusion Across the Jordan: King Abdullah, the Zionist Movement and the Partition of Palestine (New York, 1988):.

Shohat, 2017. E. Shohat On the Arab-Jew, Palestine, and Other Displacements. Selected Writings. (London, 2017).

———. 2006. Le sionisme du point de vue de ses victimes juives. Les juifs orientaux en Israel. (Paris, 2006.

Sitta. 2008. S. Abu Sitta. "The Implementation of the Right of Return." Palestine - Israel Journal of Politics, Economics & Culture 15/16 (4/1): 23-30

Silberstein, 2008. L. S. Silberstein (ed.) Postzionism: a Reader. (New Brunswick, N.J., 2008)

———.1999. The Postzionism debates: Knowledge and Power in Israeli Culture. (New York, 1999).

Sizer, 2007. S. Sizer, Zion's Christian Soldiers? (London, 2007).

Sprinzak 1991. E. Sprinzak, The Ascendance of Israel's Radical Right. New York, (Oxford, 1991.

Steiner 1998. G. Steiner. “The Hollow Miracle.” En Language and Silence: Essays on Language, Literature, and the Inhuman. Pgs. 95–109. (London, 1998).

———, 1996 Our homeland, the text, en No Passion Spent. Essays 1978-1996, (N. York, 1996).

Sternhell 2013 [1996. 2004]. Z. Sternhell, Los orígenes de Israel. Las raíces profundas de una realidad conflictiva (B. Aires, 2013)

———, 2002, “Por un nacionalismo abierto, por un sionismo liberal”, Claves de Razón Práctica Vol. 123 Pags. 4-12

Sznajder 2018. M. Sznajder Historia Mínima de Israel. (Madrid:, 2018).

Veracini 2013. L. Veracini. The Other Shift: Settler Colonialism, Israel, and the Occupation Journal of Palestine Studies. Vol. 42 Issue 2 Pages 26-42

Yiftachel 2006. O. Yiftachel. Ethnocracy: Land and Identity Politics in Israel/Palestine (Philadelphia, 2006)

———, 1998, “‘Ethnocracy’: the Politics of Judaising Israel/Palestine’, Constellations: International Journal of Critical and Democratic Theory, Vol. 6: 3: 364-390).